Are intubation conditions using rocuronium equivalent to those using succinylcholine?
Academic Emergency Medicine · 2002-08-01 · Meta-analysis
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the intubation conditions created by rocuronium are equivalent to those of succinylcholine during rapid-sequence induction (RSI). METHODS: Medline, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register were searched for randomized clinical trials (RCTs). The search strategy included all generic and trade names for succinylcholine and rocuronium, anesthesia, neuromuscular blockade, and a validated RCT filter. Intubation conditions were a required outcome. Two reviewers assessed studies for eligibility, data extraction, and quality. Intubation conditions were scored with Goldberg's scale (excellent conditions defined as clear vocal cords, easy tube insertion, and no cough). A-priori subgroup analysis was conducted for the sedative, use of opioids, true versus modified RSI, age group, and the dose of rocuronium. Data were analyzed with Metaview 4.1 for relative risk (RR) of achieving excellent intubation conditions. A sample size calculation determined that n = 468 is required for equivalence. RESULTS: Forty articles were identified; ten articles were excluded by the inclusion criteria, two were duplicate publications, and two had insufficient data. Therefore, 26 studies were analyzed. Overall, rocuronium was inferior to succinylcholine, with a RR = 0.87 (95% CI = 0.81 to 0.94) (N = 1,606). However, intubation conditions were similar in the propofol subgroup, with a RR = 0.96 (95% CI = 0.87 to 1.06) (N = 640). Failed intubations (N = 28) were equivalent in the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, succinylcholine creates excellent intubation conditions more reliably than rocuronium. If a second-line agent is required, rocuronium used with propofol creates intubation conditions equivalent to those with succinylcholine.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Anaesthetics · Muscle relaxants · Propofol · Rocuronium · Rapid sequence intubation · Suxamethonium
Related articles
- Rocuronium versus succinylcholine for rapid sequence induction intubation. (Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2015)
- Impact of the intubation model on the efficacy of rocuronium during rapid sequence intubation: systematic review of randomized trials. (Acta Anaesthesiol Scand, 2007)
- Collective Review of the Status of Rapid Sequence Intubation Drugs of Choice in Trauma in Low- and Middle-Income Settings (Prehospital, Emergency Department and Operating Room Setting). (World J Surg, 2017)
- [Different levels of experience with anesthetic agents of German emergency physicians : Results of an online survey]. (Anaesthesist, 2018)
- Analgesia and Sedation Related to the Use of Long-Acting Neuromuscular Blockers: A Narrative Review. (Air Med J, 2025)
- Postintubation Sedation After a Formulary Change From Succinylcholine to Rocuronium in a Critical Care Transport Organization. (Air Med J, 2022)