Clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of prehospital intravenous fluids in trauma patients.
Health technology assessment (Winchester, England) · 2004-06-01 · Systematic review
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To systematically review the evidence on the effectiveness (in terms of mortality and morbidity) of prehospital intravenous (i.v.) fluid replacement, compared with no i.v. fluid replacement or delayed fluid replacement, in trauma patients with no head injury who have haemorrhage-induced hypotension due to trauma. DATA SOURCES: Electronic databases, relevant websites, handsearching, expert contacts. REVIEW METHODS: Search strategies were defined to identify randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and previous systematic reviews relating to the use of i.v. fluids in a prehospital (or other) setting compared to no fluids or delayed fluids. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to identified studies, and key quality criteria of included studies were checked. Data were extracted independently by two reviewers. Economic evaluations were also systematically sought and appraised. RESULTS: Four relevant RCTs were identified, three of which were poorly designed and/or conducted. One good-quality RCT suggested that i.v. fluids may be harmful in patients with penetrating injuries. No evidence was found on the relative effectiveness of i.v. fluids in patients with blunt versus penetrating trauma. No reliable evidence was found from systematic reviews to suggest that a particular type of fluid is more beneficial compared to another type, although there was a trend favouring crystalloids over colloids. The relative costs of using i.v. fluids versus not using them were found to be very similar and changes in the use of fluids would therefore have no cost consequences for the ambulance service. A more detailed cost-effectiveness analysis would require further information on the relative consequences (mortality, morbidity) of different resuscitation strategies. CONCLUSIONS: The review found no evidence to suggest that prehospital i.v. fluid resuscitation is beneficial, and some evidence that it may be harmful. This evidence is however not conclusive, particularly for blunt trauma. A UK Consensus Statement, and to a lesser extent the UK Joint Royal Colleges Ambulance Liaison Committee guidelines represent a more cautious approach to fluid management than previously advocated and are therefore consistent with the limited evidence base. Further research is required on hypotensive (cautious) resuscitation versus delayed or no fluid replacement, particularly in blunt trauma. There is also a need for an improvement in the quality of data collection and analysis of routinely collected ambulance call-out data.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Cost & cost-effectiveness · Crystalloids · Fluids & blood · Intravenous access · Mortality & survival
Related articles
- Timing and volume of fluid administration for patients with bleeding. (Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2014)
- Association between prehospital fluid resuscitation with crystalloids and outcome of trauma patients in Asia by a cross-national multicenter cohort study. (Sci Rep, 2022)
- Resuscitation with blood products in patients with trauma-related haemorrhagic shock receiving prehospital care (RePHILL): a multicentre, open-label, randomised, controlled, phase 3 trial. (Lancet Haematol, 2022)
- Prehospital intravenous fluid administration is associated with higher mortality in trauma patients: a National Trauma Data Bank analysis. (Ann Surg, 2011)
- Reanalysis of prehospital intravenous fluid administration in patients with penetrating truncal injury and field hypotension. (Am Surg, 2007)
- Prehospital interventions for penetrating trauma victims: a prospective comparison between Advanced Life Support and Basic Life Support. (Injury, 2013)