Adequacy of online medical command communication and emergency medical services documentation of informed refusals.
Academic Emergency Medicine · 2005-10-01 · Observational study
Abstract
BACKGROUND: In the out-of-hospital setting, when emergency medical services (EMS) providers respond to a 9-1-1 call and encounter a patient who wishes to refuse medical treatment and/or transport to the hospital, the EMS providers must ensure the patient possesses medical decision-making capacity and obtain an informed refusal. In the city of Cleveland, Ohio, Cleveland EMS completes a nontransport worksheet that prompts the paramedics to evaluate specific patient characteristics that can influence medical decision-making capacity and then discuss the risks of refusing with the patient. Cleveland EMS then contacts an online medical command (OLMC) physician to authorize the refusal. OLMC calls are recorded for review. OBJECTIVES: To assess the ability of EMS to determine medical decision-making capacity and obtain an informed refusal of transport. METHODS: This study was a retrospective review of a cohort of recorded OLMC refusal calls and of the accompanying written documentation by Cleveland EMS. The completeness of the verbal communication between the paramedic and OLMC physician and the written documentation on the nontransport worksheet were measured as surrogate markers of the adequacy of determining medical decision-making capacity and obtaining an informed refusal. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-seven OLMC calls for patient-initiated refusals were reviewed. Vital signs and alertness/orientation were verbally communicated more than 83% of the time. The presence of head injury, presence of alcohol or drug intoxication, and presence of hypoglycemia were verbally communicated less than 31% of the time. Verbal communication stating that the risks of refusing had been discussed with the patient occurred 44.5% of the time. The written documentation of the refusal encounter was more complete, exceeding 95% for vital signs and alertness/orientation, and exceeding 80% for the remaining patient characteristics. The rate of written documentation that the risks of refusing had been discussed with the patient was 48.7%. Discrepancies between the verbal and written paramedic reports were clinically insignificant. CONCLUSIONS: Paramedic and OLMC physician communication for patients refusing out-of-hospital medical treatment and/or transport is inadequate in the Cleveland EMS system. A written nontransport worksheet improves documentation of the refusal encounter but does not ensure that every patient who refuses possesses medical decision-making capacity and the capacity to provide an informed refusal.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Communication & handover · Ethics · Medical direction & oversight · Paramedics & EMTs
Related articles
- Emergency Medical Services Clinicians' Perspectives on Pediatric Non-Transport. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2023)
- What factors influence ambulance conveyance decisions when dealing with acutely unwell children? A systematic literature review. (Emerg Med J, 2026)
- Compassion under lights: navigating grief and ethics in emergency medical services (Journal of Paramedic Practice, 2026)
- The experiences of patients not conveyed after evaluation by emergency medical services in Southwest Finland - A qualitative survey study. (Australas Emerg Care, 2024)
- Consultation Processes With Helicopter Emergency Medical Service Physicians in Finnish Prehospital Emergency Care: The Paramedics' Perspective. (Air Med J, 2023)
- Emergency Medical Technicians' Experiences of the Challenges of Prehospital Care Delivery During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study. (Ethiop J Health Sci, 2021)