Prehospital emergency medical services.
CJEM · 2000-10-01 · Observational study
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Our primary objectives were to estimate how frequently emergency medical technicians with defibrillation skills (EMT-Ds) are forced to deal with prehospital do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders, to assess their comfort in doing so, and to describe the prehospital care provided to patients with DNR orders in a system without a prehospital DNR policy (i.e., where resuscitation is mandatory). METHODS: Using Dillman methodology, the authors developed a 13-item survey and mailed it to 382 of 764 EMT-Ds in the metropolitan Toronto area. Responses were evaluated using 5-point Likert scales, limited-option and open-ended questions. Narrative responses were categorized. Two authors independently categorized narrative responses from 20 surveys, and kappa values for agreement beyond chance were determined. RESULTS: Among 382 EMT-Ds surveyed, 236 (62%) responded, of whom 221 (94%) answered the questionnaire. Overall, 126 of 219 (58%) indicated that they were called to resuscitate patients with DNR orders "sometimes," "frequently," or "all the time." In such situations, 22 of 207 (11%) stated they would honour the DNR order and 55 of 207 (27%) would honour the order but appear to provide basic resuscitation, in order to adhere to mandatory resuscitation regulations. Willingness to honour a DNR order did not vary by years of emergency medical service. EMT-Ds cited concern for the family and the patient, fear of repercussions and conflict with personal ethics as key factors contributing to this ethical dilemma. If legally allowed to honour DNR orders, 212 of 221 (96%) respondents would be comfortable with a written order and 137 of 220 (62%) with a verbal order. CONCLUSIONS: Prehospital DNR orders are common, and a significant number of EMT-Ds disregard current regulations by honouring them. EMT-Ds would be more comfortable with written than verbal DNR orders. An ethical prehospital DNR policy should be developed and applied.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Advance directives & DNR · Ethics · Paramedics & EMTs
Related articles
- Developing quality indicators for the appropriateness of resuscitation in prehospital atraumatic cardiac arrest. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2007)
- Resuscitation attempts in patients with do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation decisions attended by emergency medical services: contributing factors and predictors. (Br Paramed J, 2026)
- Advanced do-not-attempt-resuscitation directives and emergency medical services for out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary arrest patients in Japan: a pilot study. (Acute Med Surg, 2021)
- Prehospital Providers' Perspectives about Online Medical Direction in Emergency End-of-Life Decision-Making. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2022)
- [Emergency medical treatment of palliative care patients at the end of life: regulatory emergency medical care framework--a case control investigation of medical intervention and advance directives]. (Anaesthesist, 2009)
- Withholding advanced cardiac life support in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a prospective study. (Resuscitation, 2008)