A geospatial analysis of persons opting out of an exception from informed consent out-of-hospital clinical trial.
Resuscitation · 2008-11-17 · Observational study
Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVE: For trials involving exception from informed consent, some IRBs require that community members be allowed to "opt out" prior to enrollment. We tested for geospatial clustering of opt-out requests and the associated census tract characteristics in one study region. METHODS: This was a retrospective study at a single site of a multicenter exception from informed consent resuscitation trial. We collected and geocoded mailing addresses for persons requesting opt-out bracelets over 16 months, then tested for geospatial clustering using geographic information systems (GIS) analysis. Characteristics for tracts with and without bracelet clustering were compared using univariate tests, multivariable regression, and classification and regression tree (CART) analysis. RESULTS: We received 395 phone calls requesting 718 bracelets, of which 673 were analyzable. Of 397 census tracts in the region, 208 (52%) had at least one request and 38 (10%) demonstrated clustering. In multivariable models, an increasing proportion of family households (OR .90, 95%CI .85-.93), veterans (OR .91, 95%CI .81-1.02), and renters (OR .96, 95%CI .92-.99) were associated with lower odds of requesting an opt-out bracelet, while census tracts with higher income had higher odds of opting-out (OR 1.07, 95%CI 1.02-1.11). Using CART, the proportion of family households and graduate education identified the majority of opt-out requests by census tracts (cross-validation sensitivity 92%, specificity 56%). CONCLUSIONS: Opt-out requests for an exception from informed consent trial at one study site were geographically clustered and associated with certain population demographics. These findings may help identify key target groups for community consultation in future trials.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Equity & disparities · Ethics · Research methods & trial conduct
Related articles
- The random dialing survey as a tool for community consultation for research involving the emergency medicine exception from informed consent. (Ann Emerg Med, 2009)
- Community consultation for Exception from Informed consent (EFIC) before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Resusc Plus, 2022)
- Prehospital Stroke Treatment Trials in Conventional EMS Settings: An Expert Consensus Statement on Operational, Ethical, and Technological Priorities. (Stroke, 2026)
- Multicenter social media community consultation for an exception from informed consent trial of the XStat device (PhoXStat trial). (J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2022)
- Variation in time to notification of enrollment and rates of withdrawal in resuscitation trials conducted under exception from informed consent. (Resuscitation, 2021)
- Food and Drug Administration and Institutional Review Board Approval of a Novel Prehospital Informed Consent Process for Emergency Research. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2021)