Comparison of intravenous and intraosseous access by pre-hospital medical emergency personnel with and without CBRN protective equipment.
Resuscitation · 2009-10-24 · Randomised trial
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Rapid intravascular access is a prerequisite component of emergency care and resuscitation. Peripheral intravenous (IV) access is the first-choice for most of the medical or trauma patients, but may be delayed in emergency conditions because of various difficulties. Elsewhere, intraosseous (IO) access may now be easily performed with a new semi-automatic battery-powered IO-insertion device (EZ-IO. The aim of this study was to compare the overall time to establish IO infusion with the EZ-IO device and the equivalent time for peripheral IV infusion, performed by emergency personnel in standard (No-CBRN) and in chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear (CBRN) protective equipment. METHODS: Nine nurses and 16 physicians randomly performed 4 procedures on a training manikin: IV and IO access under No-CBRN conditions and IV and IO under CBRN conditions. The time for each infusion attempt included all the steps essential for a simulated safe clinical use of infusion. RESULTS: Under No-CBRN conditions, the time to establish IO infusion was shorter than the equivalent IV time (50+/-9 vs 70+/-30s). Similarly, under CBRN conditions, the time for IO infusion was shorter than for IV infusion (65+/-17 vs 104+/-30s). The mean time saved by IO infusion over IV infusion was respectively 20+/-24s (P<0.001) and 39+/-20s (P<0.001) under No-CBRN and CBRN conditions. CONCLUSION: The time to establish IO infusion was significantly shorter than that for peripheral IV infusion, under both No-CBRN and CBRN conditions. Further clinical studies are required to confirm that IO access would effectively save time over IV access in real pre-hospital emergency settings.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Intravenous access · Intraosseous access · Low- and middle-income settings
Related articles
- Impact of chemical, biological, radiation, and nuclear personal protective equipment on the performance of low- and high-dexterity airway and vascular access skills. (Resuscitation, 2009)
- IO versus IV access while wearing personal protective equipment in a HazMat scenario. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2007)
- Usefulness and Problems of Intraosseous Infusion with the Bone Injection Gun™ Using Simulators Under Confined Space Conditions (Hong Kong Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2014)
- Pre-hospital management of spinal injuries in a natural disaster. (J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad, 2011)
- En route intraosseous access performed in the combat setting. (Am J Disaster Med, 2016)
- [Development and validation of a course concept for Tactical Medical Mining Rescue : Standardized training curriculum for mine rescue teams]. (Med Klin Intensivmed Notfmed, 2022)