Waiver of informed consent in prehospital emergency health research in Australia.
Monash Bioethics Review · 2010-03-01 · Other / unclear
Abstract
Informed consent is a vital part of ethical research. In emergency health care research environments such as ambulance services and emergency departments, it is sometimes necessary to conduct trial interventions or observations without patient consent. At times where treatment is time critical, it may be impossible or inappropriate to seek consent from next of kin. Emergency medicine is one of the few areas where the process of informed consent can be waived to allow research to proceed without patient consent. This article will explore the ethics of informed consent in the prehospital emergency research context. This will include an overview of current Australian guidelines for ethical research, and recent changes in law internationally which have affected the conduct of international emergency health research. An overview of the ethical reasoning behind the waiver of informed consent in emergency research is presented, also addressing issues relating to emergency health research such as proxy consent, unconscious patients, and patient decision making capacity. The unusual circumstances encountered in the prehospital ambulance environment will also be discussed, including the dependent and coercive relationship between patients and ambulance professionals, and a lack of alternatives for care and transport for patients who refuse consent. The conflict arising from differences in medical culture and values between patients and health care professionals will also briefly be discussed. It will be argued that, while emergency care research should not require informed consent due to the restrictions of time and dependent nature of the relationship between patient and health professional, emergency health researchers still have a responsibility to consider the patients' perspective when considering the ethical issues of an emergency research project, particularly in the prehospital environment.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Ethics · Research methods & trial conduct
Related articles
- The acceptability of delayed consent for prehospital emergency care research in the Western Cape province of South Africa. (PLoS One, 2022)
- Multicenter social media community consultation for an exception from informed consent trial of the XStat device (PhoXStat trial). (J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2022)
- Variation in time to notification of enrollment and rates of withdrawal in resuscitation trials conducted under exception from informed consent. (Resuscitation, 2021)
- Food and Drug Administration and Institutional Review Board Approval of a Novel Prehospital Informed Consent Process for Emergency Research. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2021)
- Involving adults who lack capacity in research: ethical and legal challenges for the pre-hospital and emergency medicine context (Journal of Paramedic Practice, 2016)
- Single-site community consultation for emergency research in a community hospital setting. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2014)