Embedding a surgeon in a civilian tactical team reduces resource utilization and is cost effective.
American Journal of Disaster Medicine · 2014-01-01 · Observational study
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: This study evaluates whether embedding a surgeon in a civilian tactical team (Special Weapons and Tactics [SWAT]) reduces resource utilization during training or deployment and is cost effective. DESIGN: Prospective, non-interventional. PARTICIPANTS: All tactical police surgeon (TPS) activities (2011-2013) were prospectively captured via databases (Bento and Excel) including days of activity, training and deployment care (team members, suspects, and bystanders), academic activity, costs incurred for equipment and training, as well as costs avoided by onscene care and evaluation. Umbrella activities related to non-SWAT care and system referral were recorded. INTERVENTIONS: None. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Resource utilization, costs, and outcomes derived from embedding a surgeon in a civilian tactical team. RESULTS: There were 24 days of training and two deployments; 3 days of staff coverage were required. Team members required 18 distinct care episodes; no suspects required care. Bystander care was required twice; both were treated on-scene avoiding transport and hospital care. Non-SWAT care occurred 36 times. No complications occurred except for one urinary track infection. Comorbid medical condition evaluation and management advice in non-SWAT officers, spouses, or significant others occurred 24 times. New health system referral occurred 26 times. Total TPS equipment charges ($6,000) were offset by reduced scene transport ($3,000) and hospital care ($4,000), as well as reduced team member hospital care ($9,000) leading to a net Police Department (PD) charge surplus of (+)$9,000. New referral initial evaluation ($10,400) and operative charges ($30,800) were balanced against lost work ($6,500/d × 3d = $21,500) for a net health system charge surplus of (+)$19,700. One international presentation, three local presentations, and four peer-reviewed and five lay press publications accrued from these activities. CONCLUSIONS: A TPS reduces scene and Emergency Department resource utilization and increases new patient health system entry. Establishing a TPS is cost effective for a PD and an academic health system and supports academic productivity but may not be supportable without nonclinical days.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Cost & cost-effectiveness · Military & tactical · Prehospital physicians · Fire service & police
Related articles
- Enhancing Tactical Paramedicine Response Efficiency and Effectiveness: Lessons from the Bataclan Concert Hall Incident. (J Spec Oper Med, 2025)
- Ethical considerations in embedding a surgeon in a military or civilian tactical team. (Prehosp Disaster Med, 2012)
- Tactical emergency medical support: physician involvement and injury patterns in tactical teams. (J Emerg Med, 2008)
- Embedded military medical support in high-risk police operations: Analysis of 242 operations. (J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2026)
- Medical support for law enforcement-extended operations incidents. (Am J Disaster Med, 2014)
- Resident involvement in civilian tactical emergency medicine. (J Emerg Med, 2010)