Emergent Access to the Airway and Chest in American Football Players.
Journal of Athletic Training · 2015-05-14 · Quasi-experimental
Abstract
CONTEXT: American football has the highest rate of fatalities and catastrophic injuries of any US sport. The equipment designed to protect athletes from these catastrophic events challenges the ability of medical personnel to obtain neutral spine alignment and immobilization during airway and chest access for emergency life-support delivery. OBJECTIVE: To compare motion, time, and difficulty during removal of American football helmets, face masks, and shoulder pads. DESIGN: Quasi-experimental, crossover study. SETTING: Controlled laboratory. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: We recruited 40 athletic trainers (21 men, 19 women; age = 33.7 ± 11.2 years, height = 173.1 ± 9.2 cm, mass = 80.7 ± 17.1 kg, experience = 10.6 ± 10.4 years). INTERVENTION(S): Paired participants conducted 16 trials in random order for each of 4 helmet, face-mask, and shoulder-pad combinations. An 8-camera, 3-dimensional motion-capture system was used to record head motion in live models wearing properly fitted helmets and shoulder pads. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Time and perceived difficulty (modified Borg CR-10). RESULTS: Helmet removal resulted in greater motion than face-mask removal, respectively, in the sagittal (14.88°, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 13.72°, 16.04° versus 7.04°, 95% CI = 6.20°, 7.88°; F(1,19) = 187.27, P < .001), frontal (7.00°, 95% CI = 6.47°, 7.53° versus 4.73°, 95% CI = 4.20°, 5.27°; F1,19 = 65.34, P < .001), and transverse (7.00°, 95% CI = 6.49°, 7.50° versus 4.49°, 95% CI = 4.07°, 4.90°; F(1,19) = 68.36, P < .001) planes. Face-mask removal from Riddell 360 helmets took longer (31.22 seconds, 95% CI = 27.52, 34.91 seconds) than from Schutt ION 4D helmets (20.45 seconds, 95% CI = 18.77, 22.12 seconds) or complete ION 4D helmet removal (26.40 seconds, 95% CI = 23.46, 29.35 seconds). Athletic trainers required less time to remove the Riddell Power with RipKord (21.96 seconds, 95% CI = 20.61°, 23.31° seconds) than traditional shoulder pads (29.22 seconds, 95% CI = 27.27, 31.17 seconds; t(19) = 9.80, P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Protective equipment worn by American football players must eventually be removed for imaging and medical treatment. Our results fill a gap in the evidence to support current recommendations for prehospital emergent management in patients wearing protective football equipment. Helmet face masks and shoulder pads with quick-release designs allow for clinically acceptable removal times without inducing additional motion or difficulty.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Related articles
- Best Practices and Current Care Concepts in Prehospital Care of the Spine-Injured Athlete in American Tackle Football March 2-3, 2019; Atlanta, GA. (J Athl Train, 2020)
- Maintaining neutral sagittal cervical alignment after football helmet removal during emergency spine injury management. (Spine (Phila Pa 1976), 2012)
- Management of the helmeted athlete with suspected cervical spine injury. (Am J Sports Med, 2004)
- Face mask removal is safer than helmet removal for emergent airway access in American football. (Spine J, 2014)
- The riddell ripkord system for shoulder pad removal in a cervical spine injured athlete: a paradigm shift. (Int J Sports Phys Ther, 2011)
- The combined tool approach for face mask removal during on-field conditions. (J Athl Train, 2008)