Billing diagnoses do not accurately identify out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients: An analysis of a regional healthcare system.
Resuscitation · 2015-10-18 · Registry study
Abstract
BACKGROUND: International Classification of Diseases 9th Edition's Clinical Modification (ICD-9CM) codes are frequently used in health services research. We tested the operating characteristics of ICD-9CM codes for identifying out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) subjects. METHODS: We used ICD-9CM codes to generate an "administrative cohort" of subjects treated after possible OHCA at one of six emergency departments (EDs) between January 2010 and April 2014. We performed a structured chart review to determine proportion of this administrative cohort with actual OHCA (true positive rate for the ICD-9CM-based search method). The largest study site maintains a prospective registry of consecutive OHCA subjects, which we used to construct a "registry cohort". We used this cohort to calculate the sensitivity of the ICD-9CM-based search strategy at this site, and compared in-hospital mortality and discharge dispositions between the two cohorts using Chi-square tests. RESULTS: ICD-9CM codes identified 2461 subjects that comprised the administrative cohort. Of these, the true positive rate for actual OHCA on chart review was 40%. ICD9-CM code sensitivity was 100% for subjects coded as dead on arrival and 19% for subjects coded as surviving to ED disposition. There were 609 OHCA subjects in the registry cohort and 268 subjects in the administrative cohort who presented to registry site. Only 26 subjects appeared in both cohorts. In-hospital mortality was significantly higher in the administrative cohort than the registry cohort (91% vs. 61%, p<0.001), and hospital discharge disposition of survivors was less favorable (p<0.001). Neither difference persisted after excluding subjects surviving <6h. CONCLUSION: Compared to a prospective registry, ICD-9CM codes are an insensitive method to identify OHCA subjects. Moreover, ICD-9CM codes identify a biased sample of the OHCA population with higher mortality.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Research methods & trial conduct
Related articles
- Probabilistic Linkage of Prehospital and Outcomes Data in Out-of-hospital Cardiac Arrest. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2015)
- A link to improve stroke patient care: a successful linkage between a statewide emergency medical services data system and a stroke registry. (Acad Emerg Med, 2010)
- How do you update a global standard? A critical appraisal of the 2024 update of the Utstein out-of-hospital cardiac arrest registry template. (Resusc Plus, 2026)
- Are We Measuring What Matters? Re-Examining National Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest Outcome Indicators. (Emerg Med Australas, 2026)
- Age and sex differences in the sensitivity of ICD-10 diagnostic codes for identifying patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the British Columbia cardiac arrest registry: a retrospective cohort study. (Resuscitation, 2026)
- Towards advancing Out-of-Hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) registries globally: Considerations from the global OHCA registry (GOHCAR) collaborative. (Resusc Plus, 2024)