Lived experience of involuntary transport under mental health legislation.
International Journal of Mental Health Nursing · 2016-11-29 · Qualitative study
Abstract
Police have historically been responsible for transporting people during a mental health crisis in Australia. A major change to the New South Wales (NSW) Mental Health Act (MHA) in 2007 expanded the range of coercive transportation agencies to include NSW Ambulance (paramedics) and NSW Health (mental health nurses). Anecdotal reports, however, describe a lack of clarity around how these changes should be implemented in practice. This research aims to explore this lack of clarity through qualitative analysis of interviews with people with the lived experience of involuntary transport under the MHA. Sixteen interviews were conducted; most (n = 14) interviews in northern NSW regions: six with people who had been transported (consumers), four with carers, and six with service providers (two police, one paramedic, and three mental health nurses). For consumers and carers, the police response was often perceived as too intense, particularly if the person was not violent. Carers were often conflicted by having to call for emergency intervention. Service providers were frustrated by a lack of a coordinated interagency response, resourcing issues, delays at emergency departments, and lack of adequate training. A central theme across all groups was the importance of communication styles. As one participant (consumer) said: 'Everybody needs a lesson in kindness'. All groups agreed that high-risk situations necessitate police involvement. However, invocation of the MHA during a high-risk situation is fraught with stress and difficulties, leaving little room for empathetic communications. Effective and diverse, evidence-based, early intervention strategies - both consensual and non-consensual - are necessary to reduce the requirement for police involvement in mental health transports.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Ambulance & prehospital nurses · Clinician perspective · Communication & handover · Interagency collaboration · Paramedics & EMTs · Fire service & police
Related articles
- Police and Behavioral Health Professionals' Experiences with a Hybrid Co-response Approach to Mental Health Crisis Intervention: Qualitative Findings. (J Behav Health Serv Res, 2026)
- Exploring competence in mental health crisis management: a qualitative study of Norwegian prehospital emergency medical personnel. (BMJ Open, 2025)
- Police and mental health clinician partnership in response to mental health crisis: A qualitative study. (Int J Ment Health Nurs, 2015)
- 'An accident waiting to happen' - experiences of police officers, paramedics, and mental health clinicians involved in 911-mental health crises: a cross-sectional survey. (J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs, 2023)
- Cairns Mental Health Co-Responder Project: Essential elements and challenges to programme implementation. (Int J Ment Health Nurs, 2020)
- Barriers and facilitators to implementing an urban co-responding police-mental health team. (Health Justice, 2018)