Inexperienced but Confident: A Survey of Advanced Life Support Providers and Life-saving Interventions in the Israel Defense Forces.
Military Medicine · 2021-01-25 · Observational study
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to assess the current experience of Israel Defense Forces' (IDF) advanced life support (ALS) providers in performing life-saving interventions (LSIs), the rate of doctors and paramedics achieving the Trauma and Combat Medicine Branch benchmarks, and the rate of providers feeling confident in performing the interventions although not achieving the benchmarks. METHODS: This study was based on an online survey delivered to IDF ALS providers. The survey investigated demographics; experience in performing endotracheal intubation, cricothyroidotomy, tube thoracostomy, and intraosseous access on human patients; and confidence in performing these LSIs. All benchmarks chosen referred to the number of times performed in the previous year. The benchmarks were 20 for intubation, 3 for cricothyroidotomy, 4 for tube thoracostomy, and 3 for intraosseous access. RESULTS: During the survey period, 175 IDF ALS providers started the survey, but only 138 (79%) completed it, 93 (67%) of them were paramedics. Doctors had higher rates than paramedics of failing to achieve the benchmarks for intubation (96 vs. 57%, P < .001) and intraosseous access (100 vs. 66%, P < .001). All respondents failed to achieve the benchmark for cricothyroidotomy, and all but one paramedic failed to achieve the tube thoracostomy benchmark. Doctors had lower rates of high confidence when failing to achieve the benchmark for intubation (35 vs. 64%, P = .008) and intraosseous access (7 vs. 31%, P = .005) compared to paramedics. CONCLUSION: IDF ALS providers have alarmingly limited experience in performing LSIs. Many of them are confident in their ability despite not achieving evidence-based benchmarks. Additional training is required, maybe as a part of an annual medical fitness test.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Clinician perspective · Cricothyroidotomy · Endotracheal intubation · Intraosseous access · Military & tactical · Paramedics & EMTs · Prehospital physicians · Thoracostomy
Related articles
- Training modalities and self-confidence building in performance of life-saving procedures. (Mil Med, 2012)
- Effect of night vision goggles on performance of advanced life support skills by emergency personnel. (Mil Med, 2006)
- Timings of pre-hospital life-saving interventions in mass casualty incidents: an observational simulation study. (Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med, 2025)
- Prehospital trauma experience of the Israel defense forces on the Syrian border 2013-2017. (J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2019)
- High Success Rate of Prehospital and En Route Cricothyroidotomy Performed in the Israel Defense Forces: 20 Years of Experience. (Prehosp Disaster Med, 2021)
- Exploring the characteristics of successful prehospital trauma care teams: Insights from military trauma care simulations. (J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2023)