Strengthening prehospital clinical practice guideline development in South Africa: Reflections from guideline experts.
African Journal of Emergency Medicine · 2020-10-29 · Qualitative study
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: De novo (new) guideline development methods are well described and supported by numerous examples, including comprehensive checklists. However, alternative guideline development methods, which draw from existing up to date, high quality clinical practice guidelines instead of re-inventing the wheel, have not been adopted so readily, despite the potential efficiencies of such methods compared to de novo development. In Africa, guideline quality and rigour of development, especially for prehospital care, remains poor. This paper firstly describes the opinions of international guideline experts on the African Federation for Emergency Medicine guideline project, and secondly updates a framework for South African prehospital guideline development. METHODS: We conducted a qualitative study of expert reviews of an evidence-based guideline development project led by the African Federation for Emergency Medicine in 2016 for prehospital care in South Africa. We purposefully sampled key international and regional guideline experts from a range of organisations. Comments and voice memos, following a terms of reference guide, were thematically analysed through manual coding. RESULTS: A total of seven experts gave feedback. Key themes revolved around existing international clinical practice guidelines not being enough to cover context specific evidence, blurring of guideline responsibilities and output, and transparency of guideline decisions and conflicts of interest. We showcase three fit-for-purpose guideline development approaches and provide an updated alternative guideline development roadmap for low-resource settings. CONCLUSION: In order to create clinical practice guidelines that clinicians trust and use on a daily basis to change lives, guideline developers need rigorous yet pragmatic approaches that are responsive to end-user needs. Reflecting on the African Federation for Emergency Medicine prehospital guideline development project in 2016, this paper presents key guiding themes to strengthen guideline development in low- and middle-income countries and other low-resource settings and provides an updated hybrid guideline development approach.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Low- and middle-income settings · Research methods & trial conduct
Related articles
- Guidance we can trust? The status and quality of prehospital clinical guidance in sub-Saharan Africa: A scoping review. (Afr J Emerg Med, 2021)
- 2022 Systematic Review of Evidence-Based Guidelines for Prehospital Care. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2023)
- A national model for developing, implementing, and evaluating evidence-based guidelines for prehospital care. (Acad Emerg Med, 2012)
- Consensus-based research priorities for post-collision care in the Western Cape province of South Africa. (Afr J Emerg Med, 2025)
- Challenges, opportunities, and priorities for tier-1 emergency medical services (EMS) development in low- and middle-income countries: A modified Delphi-based consensus study among the global prehospital consortium. (Injury, 2025)
- Recommendations for Improving the Quality of Prehospital Evidence-Based Guidelines. (Prehosp Emerg Care, 2023)