A behavioural study of obedience in health professional students.
Advances in Health Sciences Education · 2021-11-22 · Observational study
Abstract
Interprofessional Education and Collaborative Practice (IPECP) is a field of study suggested to improve team functioning and patient safety. However, even interprofessional teams are susceptible to group pressures which may inhibit speaking up (positive deviance). Obedience is one group pressure that can inhibit positive deviance leading to negative patient outcomes. To examine the influence of obedience to authority in an interprofessional setting, an experimental simulated clinical scenario was conducted with Respiratory Therapy (RT) (n = 40) and Advanced Care Paramedic (ACP) (n = 20) students. In an airway management scenario, it was necessary for students to challenge an authority, a senior anesthesiologist, to prevent patient harm. In a 2 × 2 design cognitive load and an interventional writing task designed to increase positive deviance were tested. The effect of individual characteristics, including Moral Foundations, and displacement of responsibility were also examined. There was a significant effect for profession and cognitive load: RT students demonstrated lower levels of positive deviance in the low cognitive load scenario than students in other conditions. The writing task did not have a significant effect on RT or ACP students' behaviour. The influence of Moral Foundations differed from expectations, In Group Loyalty was selected as a negative predictor of positive deviance while Respect for Authority was not. Displacement of responsibility was influential for some participants thought not for all. Other individual variables were identified for further investigation. Observational analysis of the simulation videos was conducted to obtain further insight into student behaviour in a compliance scenario. Individual differences, including experience, should be considered when providing education and training for positive deviance. Simulation provides an ideal setting to use compliance scenarios to train for positive deviance and for experimentation to study interprofessional team behaviour.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Critical care & advanced paramedics · Clinician perspective · Students · Teamwork & human factors
Related articles
- Mental Workload and Handover in Paramedics and Paramedicine Students Following Simulated Emergency Responses: Pilot Study. (Simul Healthc, 2026)
- Student paramedic experiences of group-based simulation activities used in assessment: a qualitative UK study. (BMJ Open, 2025)
- An Exploration of Student Perception Toward Interprofessional High-Fidelity Clinical Simulation. (J Med Educ Curric Dev, 2024)
- Performativity, identity formation and professionalism: Ethnographic research to explore student experiences of clinical simulation training. (PLoS One, 2020)
- A simulated wilderness exercise: the development of relational competence in paramedic students (Journal of Paramedic Practice, 2014)
- Developing situation awareness amongst nursing and paramedicine students utilizing eye tracking technology and video debriefing techniques: a proof of concept paper. (Int Emerg Nurs, 2015)