Rapid tranquilization of the agitated patient in the emergency department: A systematic review and network meta-analysis.
The American journal of emergency medicine · 2021-11-14 · Meta-analysis
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Safe and effective tranquilization of the acutely agitated patient is challenging, and head-to-head comparisons of medications are limited. We aimed to identify the most optimal agent(s) for rapid tranquilization of the severely agitated patient in the emergency department (ED). METHODS: The protocol for systematic review was registered (PROSPERO; CRD42020212534). We searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, and Cochrane Database/CENTRAL from inception to June 2, 2021. We limited studies to randomized controlled trials that enrolled adult ED patients with severe agitation and compared drugs for rapid tranquilization. Predetermined outcomes were: 1) Adequate sedation within 30 min (effectiveness), 2) Immediate, serious adverse event - cardiac arrest, ventricular tachydysrhythmia, endotracheal intubation, laryngospasm, hypoxemia, hypotension (safety), and 3) Time to adequate sedation (effect onset). We extracted data according to PRISMA-NMA and appraised trials using Cochrane RoB 2 tool. We performed Bayesian network meta-analysis (NMA) using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo method with random-effects model and vague prior distribution to calculate odds ratios with 95% credible intervals for dichotomous outcomes and frequentist NMA to calculate mean differences with 95% confidence intervals for continuous outcomes. We assessed confidence in results using CINeMA. We used surface under the cumulative ranking (SUCRA) curves to rank agent(s) for each outcome. RESULTS: Eleven studies provided data for effectiveness (1142 patients) and safety (1147 patients). Data was insufficient for effect onset. The NMA found that ketamine (SUCRA = 93.0%) is most likely to have superior effectiveness; droperidol-midazolam (SUCRA = 78.8%) is most likely to be safest. There are concerns with study quality and imprecision. Quality of the point estimates varied for effectiveness but mostly rated "very low" for safety. CONCLUSIONS: Available evidence suggests that ketamine and droperidol have intermediate effectiveness for rapid tranquilization of the severely agitated patient in the ED. There is insufficient evidence to definitively determine which agent(s) may be safest or fastest-acting. Further, direct-comparison study of ketamine and droperidol is recommended.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Anaesthetics · Antipsychotics · Ketamine · Midazolam · Sedatives & anxiolytics
Related articles
- Comparative Safety of Medications for Severe Agitation: A Geriatric Emergency Department Guidelines 2.0 Systematic Review. (J Am Geriatr Soc, 2025)
- Exploring Current Emergency Medical Services Approaches to Manage Agitated Older Adult Patients: An Analysis of Statewide Protocols. (J Am Geriatr Soc, 2026)
- Intubation of Profoundly Agitated Patients Treated with Prehospital Ketamine. (Prehosp Disaster Med, 2016)
- Prehospital management of acute behavioural disturbance: managing severe agitation in the prehospital setting - a systematic literature review. (Emerg Med J, 2026)
- Review, clinical update, and practice guidelines for excited delirium syndrome. (J Spec Oper Med, 2015)
- A National Analysis on Statewide Prehospital Adult Behavioral Sedation Protocols with a Focus on Trends in Ketamine Administration. (J Emerg Med, 2025)