Removal of the cervical collar from alpine rescue protocols? A biomechanical non-inferiority trial in real-life mountain conditions.
Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine · 2022-06-27 · Randomised trial
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Alpine skiing rescues are challenging because of the mountainous environment and risks of cervical spine motion (CSM) induced during victims' extrications (EXs) and downhill evacuations (DEs). The benefits of applying a cervical collar (CC) over manual in-line stabilization without CC (MILS) in terms of spinal motion restriction during simulated alpine rescues are undocumented. Our hypothesis was that CSM recorded using MILS alone is non-inferior to CSM recorded with a CC according to a 10 degrees margin. METHODS: A total of 32 alpine extrications and 4 downhill evacuations on different slope conditions were performed using a high fidelity mannequin designed with a motion sensors instrumented cervical spine. The primary outcome was the peak extrication 3D excursion angle (Peak 3D θEX,) of the mannequin's head. The secondary objectives were to describe the time to extrication completion (tEX) and to highlight which extrication manipulation is more likely to induce CSM. RESULTS: The median Peak 3D θEX recorded during flat terrain extrications using CC was 10.77° (95% CI 7.31°-16.45°) compared to 13.06° (95% CI 10.20°-30.36°) using MILS, and 16.09° (95% CI 9.07°-37.43°) for CC versus 16.65° (95% CI 13.80°-23.40°) using MILS on a steep slope. Peak 3D θEX with CC or using MILS during extrications were equivalent according to a 10 degrees non-inferiority hypothesis testing (p < 0.05). Time to extrication completion (tEX) was significantly reduced using MILS without CC on a flat terrain with a median duration of 237,3 s (95% CI 197.8 s, 272.2 s) compared to 358.7 s (95% CI 324.1 s, 472.4 s). During downhill evacuations, CSM with and without CC across all terrain conditions were negligible (< 5°). When CC is used; its installation manipulation induces the highest CSM. When EXs are done using MILS without CC, the logroll initiation is the manipulation inducing the highest risk of CSM. CONCLUSION: For experienced ski patrollers, the biomechanical benefits of spinal motion restriction provided by CC over MILS during alpine skiing rescues appear to be marginal and CC use negatively affects rescue time.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Extrication · Rural & remote · Spinal motion restriction · Time intervals
Related articles
- The use of extrication devices in crevasse accidents: official statement of the International Commission for Mountain Emergency Medicine and the Terrestrial Rescue Commission of the International Commission for Alpine Rescue intended for physicians, paramedics, and mountain rescuers. (Wilderness Environ Med, 2008)
- Effectiveness and safety of techniques for cervical spine immobilization in mountain rescue. (Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med, 2026)
- Burial duration, depth and air pocket explain avalanche survival patterns in Austria and Switzerland. (Resuscitation, 2016)
- Comparison of different techniques for prehospital cervical spine immobilization: Biomechanical measurements with a wireless motion capture system. (PLoS One, 2023)
- Drones reduce the treatment-free interval in search and rescue operations with telemedical support - A randomized controlled trial. (Am J Emerg Med, 2023)
- Clinical outcomes of challenging out-of-hospital hypothermia management: A retrospective assessment of DOKEI protocol. (Am J Emerg Med, 2024)