Decision-making on the fly: a qualitative study of physicians in out-of-hospital emergency medical services.
BMC Emergency Medicine · 2023-06-07 · Qualitative study
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Out-of-hospital Emergency Medical Services (OHEMS) require fast and accurate assessment of patients and efficient clinical judgment in the face of uncertainty and ambiguity. Guidelines and protocols can support staff in these situations, but there is significant variability in their use. Therefore, the aim of this study was to increase our understanding of physician decision-making in OHEMS, in particular, to characterize the types of decisions made and to explore potential facilitating and hindering factors. METHODS: Qualitative interview study of 21 physicians in a large, publicly-owned and operated OHEMS in Croatia. Data was subjected to an inductive content analysis. RESULTS: Physicians (mostly young, female, and early in their career), made three decisions (transport, treat, and if yes on either, how) after an initial patient assessment. Decisions were influenced by patient needs, but to a greater extent by factors related to themselves and patients (microsystem), their organization (mesosystem), and the larger health system (macrosystem). This generated a high variability in quality and outcomes. Participants desired support through further training, improved guidelines, formalized feedback, supportive management, and health system process redesign to better coordinate and align care across organizational boundaries. CONCLUSIONS: The three decisions were made complex by contextual factors that largely lay outside physician control at the mesosystem level. However, physicians still took personal responsibility for concerns more suitably addressed at the organizational level. This negatively impacted care quality and staff well-being. If managers instead adopt a learning orientation, the path from novice to expert physician could be more ably supported through organizational demands and practices aligned with real-world practice. Questions remain on how managers can better support the learning needed to improve quality, safety, and physicians' journey from novice to expert.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Prehospital physicians · Medical direction & oversight · Clinician perspective · Teamwork & human factors
Related articles
- Introducing an on-site Helicopter Emergency Medical Service (HEMS) physician in a Norwegian Emergency Medical Communication Centre: a focus group study on the experiences of operators and physicians. (BMJ Open, 2025)
- Structured evaluation of stress triggers in prehospital emergency medical care : An analysis by questionnaire regarding the professional groups. (Anaesthesist, 2022)
- The role of general practitioners in the pre hospital setting, as experienced by emergency medicine technicians: a qualitative study. (Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med, 2014)
- Consultation Processes With Helicopter Emergency Medical Service Physicians in Finnish Prehospital Emergency Care: The Paramedics' Perspective. (Air Med J, 2023)
- Gender-sensitive considerations of prehospital teamwork in critical situations. (Philos Ethics Humanit Med, 2024)
- A qualitative study to investigate the psychosocial effects of operational deployments on Medical Emergency Response Team personnel. (Stress Health, 2021)