*SMARTSIM* A multicenter prospective randomized trial of 3D virtual reality versus traditional patient simulation.
Journal of the American College of Emergency Physicians Open · 2023-12-29 · Randomised trial
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Simulations are an integral part of paramedic education. Technological advancements have introduced three-dimensional virtual reality patient simulations (3DVRS), offering a low-cost, accessible alternative. This study compares the impact of 3DVRS and traditional simulation on paramedic students. METHODS: Students selected from a convenience sample of 11 cohorts in 10 accredited programs distributed across the United States were allocated to 2 groups using a stratified random sampling. One group received simulations via 3DVRS, the second used traditional in-person simulation. Students were exposed to 6 scenarios over 2 h from the National Association of Emergency Medical Technicians (NAEMT) Advanced Medical Life Support (AMLS) program. Altered mental status scenarios were selected a priori by the research team containing approximately 30 potential differential diagnoses. A 50-item posttest was administered using validated cognitive items provided by Fisdap. RESULTS: A multicenter prospective randomized trial of 174 paramedic students was undertaken from April until August of 2022. The traditional simulation group was comprised of 88 students and the 3DVRS group had 86 students. A Mann-Whitney U test (U = 4064.5, n 1 = 88, n 2 = 86, p = 0.396) detected no statistical difference between two distributions or median exam score (70%), the range of values and interquartile range (IQR) for both groups: TS IQR = 64-75 (range, 32-82); 3DVRS IQR = 64-76 (range, 34-86). CONCLUSION: No difference in exam scores using 3DVRS versus traditional simulation was detected. Paramedic programs may have an effective new option when incorporating simulation with 3DVRS, potentially reducing financial and real-estate resources required with in-person simulations. Larger studies are needed to truly evaluate the impact and usability of virtual reality on paramedic education.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Related articles
- Rapid Cycle Deliberate Practice Versus Conventional Simulation for Neonatal Resuscitation Training: A Randomized Controlled Trial. (Simul Healthc, 2026)
- Effect of repeated exposure to an identical multi-user virtual reality anaphylaxis scenario on paramedic trainee performance: a randomized controlled trial. (Sci Rep, 2026)
- Immersive virtual reality versus traditional instruction for long‐term retention of cardiopulmonary resuscitation skills in medical student education: A randomized controlled trial (Hong Kong Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2026)
- 360-degree projection simulation versus traditional simulation in undergraduate paramedicine education: a pilot randomised controlled trial. (Br Paramed J, 2025)
- The Bleeding Must Be Stopped! Management in the Situation of Hemorrhages-A Prospective Randomized Controlled Prospective Simulation Study. (Healthcare (Basel), 2024)
- Learner evaluation of an immersive virtual reality mass casualty incident simulator for triage training. (BMC Digit Health, 2024)