"Some missions can be quite emotionally painful." Paramedic´s experience exercising coercion during assignments-A qualitative study.
PLoS ONE · 2024-01-01 · Qualitative study
Abstract
BACKGROUND: More than 70% of respondents in a previous survey among paramedics reported use of coercion or physical force towards patients. Coercion outside hospital is not permitted, and neither routines nor equipment intended for physical restraint is available in the Norwegian ambulance services. Paramedics carry out assignments involving use of force and coercion on unclear legal grounds, with no training in techniques or proper equipment. Attitudes and experiences of healthcare workers regarding incidents involving coercion in mental health care services are frequently reported in the research literature, yet little is known about paramedics' experiences, and which factors contribute to their moral stress. METHODS: In the period June-August 2021, almost 400 employees in the ambulance services in a county in the eastern part of Norway were invited to answer a digital questionnaire. One question had an open text field with the question "Can you say something about how you experience transporting patients where force has to be used to secure the patient during transport?". The answers were analyzed using Graneheim and Lundman's content analysis. RESULTS: We received eighty-five completed responses (response rate 21%). Force was used by 62 paramedics. Twenty-three left the text field open. The answers showed many unique responses. Content analysis resulted in two overarching themes; 1) lack of routines, equipment, and training regarding use of coercion and force in the ambulance service, and 2) paramedics were confronted with ethical dilemmas, alone and without support from legislation or management. CONCLUSIONS: The paramedics experienced discomfort related to the exercise of force and coercion during ambulance assignments due to the experience of unclear legislation, lack of training, routines, and equipment in addition to frequent ethical dilemmas and the concern about lack of support from the employer. A clearer legal basis, adapted equipment in the ambulance and regular training, will contribute to greater security in the performance of the work, which will provide safer and more caring treatment for the patients and less moral stress for the staff. With established routines, the employer will be implicitly obliged, and paramedics will be safer in the performance of their work. Ethical reflection must be offered and put into a system.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via PubMed. Reuse and removal
Tags
Clinician perspective · Ethics · Paramedics & EMTs
Related articles
- Paramedic mental health literacy and psychiatric emergencies: A qualitative pilot study in Gauteng, South Africa. (Health SA, 2026)
- Paramedic clinical decision-making in mental health care: a new theoretical approach (Journal of Paramedic Practice, 2011)
- How do emergency ambulance paramedics view the care they provide to people who self harm?: Ways and means. (Int J Law Psychiatry, 2017)
- Management of Agitation in Emergency Medical Services for Older Adults: A Qualitative Exploration. (Acad Emerg Med, 2026)
- Paramedics’ attitudes toward elderly patients’ self-determination in emergency assignments: a US context (International Journal of Emergency Services, 2024)
- Perceptions and experiences of community-based healthcare professionals in the state of Qatar having do not attempt resuscitation discussions during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Front Med (Lausanne), 2023)