A comparison of biphasic manual and semi-automatic external defibrillation
Journal of Paramedic Practice · 2023-06-02 · Systematic review
Abstract
Background: Biphasic manual defibrillation (MD) is advocated as the preferred strategy for paramedics ahead of semi-automatic external defibrillation (SAED) for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA). Methods: A systematic review involved searching CINAHL, MEDLINE and Embase academic databases. Comparative studies where both strategies were tested for time to first defibrillation (TTFD) and related Utstein-based model outcomes were examined to discern which strategy was superior. Results: Two studies met the criteria. One study found that in 4552 SAED episodes of defibrillation (30.8% of the 14 776 total defibrillation episodes), a decrease of >10% in mean TTFD (P<0.001) of an intial shockable rhythm was recorded. The same study reported an overall decrease in TTFD within 2 minutes (95% CI/P<0.001), with a 68% improved odds of receiving a shock within two minutes. SAED was associated with a 26% reduction in the risk-adjusted odds of survival (95% CI/P<0.009), attributed to cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) delays. The other examined 160 defibrillations in OHCA. The MD median TTFD was 7 seconds faster (95% CI/P<0.0001) and responsible for 20% more inappropriate shocks. Conclusions: Modern SAED is superior in reducing TTFD and inappropriate shocks. The modern SAED and MD strategies can be enhanced by interruption-reducing technology. New SAED algorithms can detect shockable rhythms in 3 seconds. More randomised studies need to be conducted using up-to-date devices. A multifaceted approach incorporating technological advancements, ongoing research and training is necessary to ensure that the most effective defibrillation strategy is employed.
Abstract © the authors or publisher, via OpenAlex. Reuse and removal
Tags
Automated external defibrillator · Paramedics & EMTs · Time intervals
Related articles
- Method for determining automatic external defibrillator need at mass gatherings. (Resuscitation, 2005)
- CPR Guidance by an Emergency Physician via Video Call: A Simulation Study. (Emerg Med Int, 2018)
- EMS defibrillation-first policy may not improve outcome in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. (Resuscitation, 2003)
- Cardiac arrests treated by ambulance paramedics and fire fighters. (Med J Aust, 2002)
- Semi-autonomous drone delivering automated external defibrillators for real out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: A Danish feasibility study. (Resuscitation, 2025)
- An innovative Hearing AED alarm system shortens delivery time of automated external defibrillator - A randomized controlled simulation study. (Resusc Plus, 2024)